Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Erie · 33 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. Alfee's Pizza

    3001 Glenwood Park Avenue

  2. Clancy's Pub & Pizza

    901 East Avenue

  3. Colony Pizza

    2664 West 8th Street

  4. Coppola’s Pizzeria

    1042 West 26th Street

  5. Domino's

    3060 West 26th Street

  6. Domino's

    5158 Peach Street

  7. Domino's

    3303 Buffalo Road

  8. Domino's

    1402 Turnpike Street

  9. Donatos Pizza

    4829 Buffalo Road

  10. Gino & Joe's NY Style Pizza

    3701 West Lake Road

  11. Little Caesars

    2897 West 26th Street

  12. Little Caesars

    1332 East Grandview Boulevard

  13. Little Caesars

    1025 Parade Street

  14. Little Caesars

    1904 West 8th Street

  15. Little Caesars

    4490 Buffalo Road

  16. Little Caesars

    725 West 38th Street

  17. Marco's Pizza

    1509 East 38th Street

  18. Maria's Pizza

    2340 West Grandview Boulevard

  19. My Dad's Pizza & Deli

    4535 Buffalo Road

  20. Oakwood Pizzeria

    861 East 38th Street

  21. Papa John's

    1713 East 38th Street

  22. Papa John's

    3870 Peach Street

  23. Patti's Pizza

    3700 Pine Avenue

  24. Pizza Hut

    1404 Peninsula Drive

  25. Pizza Hut

    4402 Buffalo Road

  26. Pizza Hut

    5050 Peach Street

  27. Pizza Pete's

    2823 West 26th Street

  28. Stevo's Pizza

    1019 State Street

  29. Valerio's

    1803 East 38th Street

  30. Valerio's

    2179 West 32nd Street

  31. Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

    724 Powell Avenue

  32. Vintage Wood Fire Pizza

    4447 West Ridge Road

  33. Virgil's Plate

    1001 West 6th Street

Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.