Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Columbus · 100 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. [Permanently Closed] Pizza Cucinova

    4044 Morse Crossing

  2. Ange's Pizza

    139 Yearling Road

  3. Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill
  4. Bellacino's Pizza
  5. Bexley Pizza Plus

    2651 East Main Street

  6. Black Dog Pizzeria

    5923 Karric Square Drive

  7. Borgata Pizza
  8. Buckeye Pizza
  9. Carsonie's Stromboli and Pizza
  10. Castello Pizza

    2577 Indianola Avenue

  11. Chuck E. Cheese
  12. Cottage Inn Pizza
  13. Cousin Vinny's Pizza

    4658 Kenny Road

  14. Dante's Pizza

    3586 Indianola Avenue

  15. Dewey's
  16. Domino's

    3730 Main Street

  17. Domino's
  18. Domino's

    2183 North High Street

  19. Domino's

    3554 Broadway

  20. Domino's

    1428 North High Street

  21. Domino's

    5864 Westerville Road

  22. Donatos Pizza
  23. Donatos Pizza

    1891 Tamarack Circle North

  24. Donatos Pizza
  25. Donatos Pizza

    1730 Hilliard-Rome Road

  26. Donatos Pizza

    920 North High Street

  27. Donatos Pizza
  28. Donatos Pizza
  29. Donatos Pizza
  30. Donatos Pizza
  31. Donatos Pizza
  32. Donatos Pizza

    377 Granville Street

  33. Donatos Pizza
  34. Donatos Pizza
  35. Donatos Pizza

    2520 Bethel Road

  36. Donatos Pizza
  37. Donatos Pizza
  38. Fibonacci's Pizzeria #1

    3055 Indianola Avenue

  39. Flyers Pizza Groveport

    296 Main Street

  40. Gant's Pizza
  41. Geo's Pizza, Subs & Wings
  42. Godfather's Pizza
  43. GoreMade Pizza

    936 North Fourth Street

  44. Grandad's Pizza

    1418 Morse Road

  45. Grandad's Pizza & Pub
  46. Grandma's Pizza & Pasta
  47. Grapevine Pizza
  48. Gresso's

    961 South High Street

  49. Happy's Pizza
  50. Harvest Pizza

    495 South Fourth Street

  51. HobNob Pizza

    2102 Tremont Center

  52. Jet's Pizza

    5691 Woerner Temple Rd

  53. Jet's Pizza

    4740 Reed Road

  54. Jet's Pizza
  55. JT's Pizza & Pub

    2390 West Dublin Granville Road

  56. Little Caesars
  57. Little Caesars
  58. Little Caesars

    2491 Hilliard – Rome Road

  59. Little Caesars
  60. Little Italy Ristorante

    480 Main Street

  61. Luna Pizza Kitchen

    2052 Crown Plaza Drive

  62. Mama Lia's Pizzeria

    3860 Lattimer Street

  63. Mama Mimi's Take 'n Bake Pizza
  64. Marco's Pizza

    5310 Hamilton Road

  65. Marco's Pizza

    4719 Reed Road

  66. Massey's Pizza
  67. Mikey's Late Night Slice

    1839 North Pearl Street

  68. Mikey’s Late Night Slice

    457 North High Street

  69. Minuteman Pizza
  70. New York Pizza Oven
  71. NY Fried Chicken and Pizza

    2057 Morse Road

  72. Oh Pizza & Brew
  73. Ohio State Pizza
  74. Padova's Pizza
  75. Panzera's Pizza
  76. Papa John's

    2906 East Main Street

  77. Papa John's

    4960 West Broad Street

  78. Papa John's

    2579 South Hamilton Road

  79. Pies and Pints

    4205 Weaverton Lane

  80. Pizza Cucinova

    1187 Olentangy River Road

  81. Pizza Fresca
  82. Pizza Hut
  83. Pizza Hut

    5121 North Hamilton Road

  84. Pizza Hut
  85. Pizza Hut

    1325 Harrisburg Pike

  86. Pizza Hut

    890 East Dublin Granville Road

  87. Pizza Hut

    1382 North High Street

  88. Pizza Rustica

    17 South High Street

  89. Pizzanos Express

    804 Parsons Avenue

  90. Rapid Fired Pizza
  91. Romeo's Pizza
  92. Rotolo's Pizza

    1749 West 5th Avenue

  93. Sarefino's Pizza

    59 Spruce Street

  94. Sbarro

    119 Easton Town Center

  95. Sicilia's Pizza

    22 E Frambes Ave

  96. Side Piece Pies
  97. Starline Diner

    4121 Main Street

  98. Tammy's Pizza
  99. Yellow Brick Pizza

    892 Oak Street

  100. Yellow Brick Pizza
Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.