Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Staten Island · 100 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. & Pizza

    1101 Morris Avenue

  2. Amalfi Coast Pizzeria & Restaurant
  3. Ambrosino's Pizzeria
  4. Ambrosino's Pizzeria

    3161 Amboy Road

  5. Amici Pizza
  6. Anthony's Pizza

    65 Church Street

  7. Avanti's Pizzeria
  8. Bel Giardino
  9. Big Apple Pizza

    13 Walnut Avenue

  10. Blaze Pizza
  11. Blaze Pizza

    1255 Raritan Road

  12. Bravo Pizza
  13. Calabria

    209 Centennial Avenue

  14. Campania
  15. Campania

    3900 Richmond Avenue

  16. Canlon's Restaurant

    1825 North Railroad Avenue

  17. Capri Pizza

    524 Boulevard

  18. Casa Nino's Pizza Bar

    1281 Arthur Kill Road

  19. Chicago Style Pizza
  20. Chuck E. Cheese
  21. Cioffi’s Restaurant-Bar-Pizzeria

    979 Stuyvesant Avenue

  22. Ciro Pizza Cafe
  23. Classic Pizza
  24. Colonia Pizza
  25. Cugini's Pizza

    361 NJ 36

  26. Delio's Pizza

    120 North Broadway Street

  27. Domenico's Pizzeria
  28. Domino's
  29. Domino's

    1208 Neptune Avenue

  30. Domino's

    448 Rahway Avenue

  31. Domino's

    3902 Richmond Avenue

  32. Domino's

    309 Route 35

  33. Domino's

    586 New Brunswick Avenue

  34. Domino's

    172 New Dorp Lane

  35. Domino's

    101 North Avenue

  36. Domino's

    309 NJ 35

  37. Dough by Licastri

    3831 Richmond Avenue

  38. Famiglia Pizzeria
  39. Felina Cucina
  40. Frank & Danny's

    4369 Amboy Road

  41. Fratelli Pizzeria
  42. Gino's Villa Monte Pizzeria & Restaurant
  43. Giuseppe's Pizza
  44. Goodfella's
  45. Goodfella's Pizzeria
  46. Goodfellows

    736 King Georges Post Road

  47. Goodfellows Pizza

    3 Johnson Lane

  48. Holliwood Mexican

    108 Smith Street

  49. il a forno a legna

    1464 Main Street

  50. Il Forno Pizzeria
  51. Italian Touch
  52. Jay's Chicken & Pizza
  53. John's Deli

    7423 Amboy Road

  54. Justino's Pizzeria

    89 Guyon Avenue

  55. Kingdom Cafe

    4350 Amboy Road

  56. Little Caesars
  57. Mama Mia Pizzeria & Cucina
  58. Michelino's Pizzaria

    79 East Milton Avenue

  59. Mike's Pizza

    1016 US 9 South

  60. Millie's of Staten Island

    185 Bricktown Way

  61. Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza
  62. Mona Lisa Pizzeria & Ristorante

    839 Annadale Road

  63. Naples Pizza
  64. Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
  65. Nonna's Pizzeria
  66. Nunzio's Kitchen

    521 Raritan Street

  67. Old Glory Kitchen & Spirits

    84 Broad Street

  68. Papa John's

    2124 Mermaid Avenue

  69. Papa John's

    2175 Hylan Boulevard

  70. Paul's Daughter
  71. Pino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    1026 Rossville Avenue

  72. Pizza Town

    205 North Wood Avenue

  73. Pizzaioli

    694 Arthur Kill Road

  74. Pizzeria Giove

    278 New Dorp Lane

  75. Pizzeria Montevideo

    531 Bayway

  76. Plaza Pizza
  77. Primo's Pizza and Restaurant

    2909 Washington Road

  78. Pronto Pizza
  79. Pronto Pizza
  80. Pronto Pizza
  81. Reggiano's Brick Oven Pizza
  82. Roman Delight Pizza
  83. Royal Pizza
  84. Salvatore & Lloyd's Pizza Place

    3850 Richmond Avenue

  85. Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza

    639 South Broad Street

  86. Saporito
  87. Saporito
  88. Sbarro
  89. Sbarro
  90. Sunset Pizza Restaurant

    645 Rossville Avenue

  91. Surf City Pizzaria

    837 Surf Avenue

  92. Surf Pizza & Wings

    2115 Surf Avenue

  93. The Square on Annadale

    833 Annadale Road

  94. Tony's Pizza
  95. Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana

    1524 Neptune Avenue

  96. Towne Deli & Pizzeria

    5373 Arthur Kill Road

  97. Villa Monte
  98. Village Maria Pizza
  99. Vinny's
  100. Zio Toto
Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.