Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Rochester · 100 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. All Star Pizza

    1628 Penfield Road

  2. Amico Pizza

    859 Ridge Road East

  3. Ardor Park Artisanal Pizza

    117 Park Avenue

  4. Benucci's Italian Restaraunt

    102 Greece Ridge Center Drive

  5. Big Deal Pizzeria & Grill

    475 Monroe Avenue

  6. Blaze Pizza
  7. Branca

    683 Pittsford-Victor Road

  8. Brooklyn Joes
  9. Cam's Pizzeria

    2341 Brighton-Henrietta Town Line Road

  10. Cam's Pizzeria

    2487 Browncroft Boulevard

  11. Capones Italian Eatery

    1811 Penfield Road

  12. Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium

    385 North Winton Road

  13. Caraglio's Pizza

    2186 Empire Boulevard

  14. Caraglio's Pizza

    1169 North Greece Road

  15. Caraglio's Pizza

    3869 Lyell Road

  16. Caraglio's Pizza

    3366 Latta Road

  17. Carbone's Pizzeria

    610 North Greece Road

  18. Chester Cab Pizza

    707 Park Avenue

  19. Chuck E. Cheese

    3130 Ridge Road West

  20. Cordello's Pizzeria

    117 Pattonwood Drive

  21. Cotoletta

    440 Elm Ridge Center Drive

  22. Create A Pizza

    766 Monroe Avenue

  23. Crust Pizza Kitchen

    211 Main Street

  24. Domino's

    2095 East Henrietta Road

  25. Domino's

    1699 Culver Road

  26. Domino's

    1667-1673 East Main Street

  27. Domino's

    785 Fairport Road

  28. Domino's

    1595 Mount Hope Avenue

  29. Dragonfly Tavern

    725 Park Avenue

  30. Ferrari Pizza bar
  31. Ferrari Pizza Bar Party Room

    349 West Commercial Street

  32. Fire Crust

    4843 West Henrietta Road

  33. GG's Pizza

    326 West Commercial Street

  34. Giuseppe's

    50 Spencerport Road

  35. Good Guys Pizza

    3313 Chili Avenue

  36. Great Northern Pizza
  37. Guida's Pizzeria

    404 Empire Boulevard

  38. Guida's Pizzeria

    1837 Penfield Road

  39. Hoagies Deli Pizza

    1615 Scottsville Road

  40. Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

    1918 Monroe Avenue

  41. JT's Pizza and Plates

    108 Main Street

  42. Little Caesars
  43. Little Caesars

    1297 Chili Avenue

  44. Little Caesars

    515 Monroe Avenue

  45. Little Venice Pizza

    742 South Avenue

  46. Lucci's Pizza

    3289 East River Road

  47. Mark's Pizzeria

    563 Titus Avenue

  48. Mark's Pizzeria

    245 Merchants Road

  49. Mark's Pizzeria

    2107 Five Mile Line Road

  50. Mark's Pizzeria

    1465 Jefferson Road

  51. Mark's Pizzeria

    1201 Bay Road

  52. Mark's Pizzeria

    3670 Mount Read Boulevard

  53. Mark's Pizzeria

    2103 Buffalo Road

  54. Martino's
  55. Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta

    3585 Buffalo Road

  56. Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta

    2838 West Ridge Road

  57. Mavrik's Pizza

    1290 Mount Hope Avenue

  58. Mr. Shoes Pizza

    1687 Mount Hope Avenue

  59. Napa Wood Fired Pizzeria

    573 Alexander Street

  60. Nino's Pizzaria

    1330 Culver Road

  61. Perri's Pizza

    1881 East Avenue

  62. Perri's Pizza

    1600 Lyell Avenue

  63. Perri's Pizza

    3105 East Henrietta Road

  64. Pizza Hut

    3920 Dewey Avenue

  65. Pizza Hut

    2255 East Ridge Road

  66. Pizza Hut

    2177 East Henrietta Road

  67. Pizza Hut

    1900 Empire Boulevard

  68. PIZZA NOTA

    192 Anderson Avenue

  69. Pizza Stop
  70. Pizza Stop

    123 State Street

  71. Pizza Wizard

    760 South Clinton Avenue

  72. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    2761 East Henrietta Road

  73. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    3187 Chili Avenue

  74. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    1822 Monroe Avenue

  75. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    20 State Street

  76. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    807 Ridge Road

  77. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    665 Pittsford-Victor Road

  78. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    2010 West Ridge Road

  79. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    702 East Ridge Road

  80. Pontillo's Pizzeria

    418 Empire Boulevard

  81. Red Zone Pizza

    240 East Main Street

  82. Sagra Italia

    155 Saint Paul Street

  83. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    751 Pittsford Victor Road

  84. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    1217 Bay Road

  85. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    1985 East Main Street

  86. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    149 East Ridge Road

  87. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    4000 Lake Avenue

  88. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    2496 West Ridge Road

  89. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    1018 South Clinton Avenue

  90. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    1324 Dewey Avenue

  91. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    433 Mount Read Boulevard

  92. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    240 West Commercial Street

  93. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    352 Jefferson Road

  94. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    2055 East Ridge Road

  95. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

    2044 Latta Road

  96. Squatcho's

    17 East Main Street

  97. Stromboli's

    130 East Avenue

  98. The Pizza Stop

    3349 Monroe Avenue

  99. Tony Pepperoni

    4164 West Henrietta Road

  100. Two Paisan's Pizzeria & Cafe
Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.