Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Buffalo · 80 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. Anchor Bar

    4300 Maple Road

  2. Avenue Pizza & Pasta

    1116 Hertel Avenue

  3. Bflo Pizza Bistro

    388 Porter Avenue

  4. Blasdell Pizza

    3904 South Park Avenue

  5. Blaze Pizza

    1595 Niagara Falls Boulevard

  6. Bob and John's La Hacienda

    1545 Hertel Avenue

  7. Bocce Club Pizza

    4200 Genesee Street

  8. Buffalo's Best Grill & Catering

    3700 Southwestern Boulevard

  9. Cappeli's Pizzeria

    3463 North Buffalo Street

  10. Chubby's Pizza

    16 French Lea Road

  11. Chuck E. Cheese

    2638 Delaware Avenue

  12. Chuck E. Cheese

    4408 Milestrip Road

  13. D'Agostino's Pizzeria

    576 Dick Road

  14. Daniela
  15. DiPaulo's Pizza

    571 Brighton Road

  16. Domino's

    3155 Delaware Avenue

  17. Domino's

    3608 Main Street

  18. Domino's

    1401 Niagara Falls Boulevard

  19. Extra Extra

    549 West Utica Street

  20. Fontana's Pizza & Sandwich Shoppe

    77 South Rossler Avenue

  21. Forno Napoli

    1280 Sweet Home Road

  22. Franco’s Pizza

    1924 Eggert Road

  23. Fry Baby Donut Co

    69 Chenango Street

  24. Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse

    5110 Main Street

  25. Gino & Joe's
  26. Gino's NY Pizza

    3500 Main Street

  27. Gino's NY Pizzeria

    1009 Elmwood Avenue

  28. He's Not Here!

    365 Niagara Boulevard

  29. Hoagie Hounds

    301 Englewood Avenue

  30. Hydraulic Hearth

    716 Swan Street

  31. Jet's Pizza

    5401 Sheridan Drive

  32. JJ's Casa-Di-Pizza

    11 East Mohawk Street

  33. John's Pizza & Subs

    4241 Delaware Avenue

  34. John's Pizza & Subs

    1436 Niagara Falls Boulevard

  35. Just Pizza

    3172 Main Street

  36. Just Pizza

    2350 Delaware Avenue

  37. Just Pizza & Wing Co

    300 Elmwood Avenue

  38. Just Pizza & Wing Co.

    2225 Colvin Boulevard

  39. La Hacienda Brighton

    Brighton Road

  40. La Nova

    357 West Ferry Street

  41. La Nova Pizzeria

    5151 Main Street

  42. Leo's Pizzeria

    South Park Avenue

  43. Little Caesars

    3009 Union Road

  44. Little Caesars

    2309 Eggert Road

  45. Little Caesars

    2290 Delaware Avenue

  46. Little Caesars
  47. Little Caesars

    3842 Harlem Road

  48. Macy's Place Pizzeria

    3100 Delaware Avenue

  49. Macy’s Place Pizzeria

    3348 Genesee Street

  50. Mattina's Pizzeria

    3744 Delaware Avenue

  51. Mike's Subs
  52. Mister Pizza

    1065 Elmwood Avenue

  53. Mo'z Pizza & Wings

    4621 Maple Road

  54. Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe

    2776 Sheridan Drive

  55. Muscarella’s Pizza
  56. Nino's Pizza

    1737 Orchard Park Road

  57. Olisi's New York Style Pizza

    2352 Sheridan Drive

  58. One Pie Pizza Co.

    2185 Clinton Street

  59. Parivaar Pub

    708 Elmwood Avenue

  60. Picasso's Pizza

    4154 McKinley Parkway

  61. Pie-O-Mine / Greens

    1725 Sheridan Drive

  62. Pie-O-Mine Greens

    3229 Southwestern Boulevard

  63. Pino's Pizza
  64. Pizza Delight

    3324 Sheridan Drive

  65. Pizza Hut

    4005 Sheridan Drive

  66. Pizza Hut

    2150 Delaware Avenue

  67. Pizza Hut

    3669 Delaware Avenue

  68. Pizza Pizza
  69. Pizza Plant Italian Pub

    125 Main Street

  70. Pizza Works
  71. Route 62 Pizzeria

    3337 Bailey Avenue

  72. Santora's Pizza Pub & Grill

    1 Walden Galleria Drive

  73. Say Cheese Pizza
  74. Slice
  75. Sorrentinos

    5640 Main Street

  76. South Park Pizza and Deli

    South Park Avenue

  77. Wegmans Pizza

    5275 Sheridan Drive

  78. WingNutz Bar and Grill

    1402 Millersport Highway

  79. Woodlawn Pizzeria & Deli

    3306 Lake Shore Road

  80. Zahz Pizza

    596 Cayuga Road

Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.