Hometown Honours

Best Pizza

Toms River · 26 on the ballot · no votes cast yet

Pre-season standings — counts are provisional and audited before the official awards cycle begins. How ranking works

How this works

Nobody has voted in this category yet — the first vote sets the lead. Tap Vote next to one business. You get a single vote here and it can’t be changed once confirmed.

  1. Anchor Inn

    400 Ocean Gate Avenue

  2. Attilio's Pizza

    944 Lakewood Road

  3. Capone's Gourmet Pizza

    17 Washington Street

  4. Charlie's Pizza

    1980 Route 37 West

  5. Daddio's Pizza
  6. Domino's

    3000 Yorktowne Boulevard

  7. Domino's

    1501 Route 37 East

  8. House of Pizza
  9. Italy's Best III Pizzeria
  10. Joey D's Pizza
  11. Linda's Pizza

    318 Ocean Gate Avenue

  12. Little Caesars
  13. Mangia Pizza
  14. Marie's Pizza
  15. MJ's Pizza Bar & Grill

    905 Bay Boulevard

  16. PaciDough's Pizza Joint
  17. Papa John's

    152 NJ 37 East

  18. Pies on Nine
  19. Pizza Hut
  20. Pizza Hut

    211 Route 37 East

  21. Pondrelli's Pizza and Kitchen

    1500 NJ-37

  22. Rosato's Pub & Pizzeria

    600 Mule Road

  23. Sal's Pizza
  24. Schiano's Pizza
  25. Schiano's Pizza

    560 Lakehurst Road

  26. STR Pizza

    399 Dover Road

Somebody missing?Add them to the ballot — new listings get reviewed within a day.

Read how listings and ranking work to see how the standings are tallied.